The Problem with checkbox sustainability is that many organizations today face the same challenge: Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) and Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) reporting has become highly structured but increasingly impersonal. Annual disclosures are rich with metrics and performance dashboards, yet they often say little about what has truly changed for people, communities, or ecosystems.
This is not because companies lack commitment. It’s because the process has become overly focused on format rather than substance. ESG, originally built on stewardship and accountability, has evolved into a technical language of metrics and frameworks that can obscure the human dimension.
If sustainability reporting is to inspire confidence and drive impact, it must reconnect with its purpose, translating action into meaning and meaning into measurable progress.
“Meaningful ESG” is not about rejecting standards; it’s about restoring purpose within them. Frameworks such as the International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB), Global Reporting Initiative (GRI), and Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) remain essential for consistency and comparability. But they should also enable organizations to communicate how sustainability outcomes are experienced, not just how they are measured.
A simple test applies: can someone reading your report understand and feel the difference your organization is making? For example:
These are not embellishments. They are evidence of integrity and maturity.
Boards often ask, “How can we improve our ESG scores?” A better question might be, “How do we make our sustainability story credible and enduring?”
Storytelling in this context is not marketing; it is translation, converting data into understanding and strategy into lived experience. When embedded in governance, storytelling supports assurance, transparency, and stakeholder trust.
Metrics provide accountability; stories provide coherence. Together, they enable ESG to function not as a compliance exercise but as a system of organizational learning.
The future of ESG reporting will not be determined by the volume of disclosure, but by its clarity, authenticity, and relevance. Stakeholders, from investors and regulators to employees and Indigenous partners, are increasingly seeking connection as well as compliance.
Effective ESG communication should:
The original intent of ESG was to align business with broader social and environmental values. Over time, the field has become defined by data, metrics, and acronyms. These are necessary, but not sufficient.
To regain credibility and momentum, companies must bring together two complementary capabilities:
Together, they turn ESG from a compliance framework into a communication framework, namely one that connects internal performance with external purpose.
Advisors play an important role in bridging these dimensions. Our task is not only to interpret standards but to interpret meaning.
At Verdensure, we help organizations communicate progress authentically, even when it is imperfect. That means designing systems that are both auditable and human: dashboards that integrate performance and perception, and impact reports that reflect stewardship rather than marketing.
We call this credible sustainability: the point where safety, trust, and impact converge.
After several years of debate and fatigue, ESG is entering a period of recalibration. Regulators are clarifying expectations, investors are demanding measurable integrity, and employees are seeking work that aligns with purpose.
Organizations that respond to this moment, by embedding credibility into governance, transparency into reporting, and empathy into communication, will not only rebuild trust but define the next era of sustainable business.
The challenge ahead is not the absence of data, but the absence of connection — the human soul of sustainability. We have built sophisticated systems to measure performance, yet often struggle to convey meaning.
If sustainability is to endure, it must once again sound like people, not policy. It must bridge the distance between metrics and meaning, because that is where credibility lives.
Ross Mitchell is a globally recognized ESG and HSSE strategist and technical specialist with over 25 years of experience driving sustainability, safety, and social impact across mining, energy, and infrastructure portfolios in more than 30 countries. As Founder of Verdensure Inc., he advises corporates, investors, and development partners on embedding ESG and SDG principles into governance, disclosure, and operational systems - building long-term credibility and resilience.
Read how they tackle today’s challenges and shape tomorrow’s solutions
